ECJ sidesteps ruling on Malta Bill 55 compatibility

Date:

Kyle Kevin
Kyle Kevin
iGaming Writer
Fact Checked

The ECJ dismissed an Austrian referral on whether Malta’s Bill 55 complies with EU law, leaving the question of its cross-border legality unresolved.

Quick Answer

Malta Bill 55 remains untested at the ECJ. The court dismissed an Austrian referral on Thursday, ruling that EU law was not necessary to settle a negligence claim between a litigation funder and its legal adviser. ECJ Press Officer Jacques Rene Zammit confirmed the judgment did not address the law’s compatibility with EU law.

In This Article
  • The Inadmissible Austrian Referral
  • Why the ECJ Found No Need to Rule
  • What Malta Bill 55 Actually Blocks
  • The Bigger EU Gambling Cases Awaiting

The ECJ dismissed an Austrian referral on Thursday concerning Malta’s Bill 55, a 2023 law that bars legal action against MGA-licensed operators and blocks enforcement of foreign judgments against them. The ruling does not answer the central question: whether the law complies with EU law.

The chain of events started in Austria, where a court refused to apply a Maltese ruling against a MGA-licensed operator. That operator had been active in Austria without a local licence. The litigation funder Spielerschutz Sigma had secured several favourable rulings for players seeking refunds from grey-market operators, then sued the adviser who had told it the law was incompatible with EU law.

The Inadmissible Austrian Referral

Spielerschutz Sigma asked an Austrian legal adviser for a preliminary view on Bill 55. The adviser concluded the law was incompatible with EU law and would not apply to enforcement proceedings in Malta. Malta’s courts rejected that reasoning and refused to apply the Austrian judgment, prompting the funder to seek compensation for the fees and losses it claimed to have incurred.

The Austrian court then sent the matter to Luxembourg, seeking clarification on how EU law should be interpreted. The ECJ declined, finding the referral inadmissible. It reasoned that the dispute was between the funder and the adviser, not between states or a state and an operator. The court could examine whether the adviser’s opinion was reasonably defensible given the law and facts available at the time without resolving Malta’s broader legal standing.

KEY FACTS
Court Decision
Inadmissible
Referring Court
Austria
Reason
Not necessary
Law in Question
Malta Bill 55
Litigation Funder
Spielerschutz
Prior ECJ Ruling
April 2026
Claim at Issue
Negligence
Status of Law
Untested

Why the ECJ Found No Need to Rule

The court’s reasoning was procedural rather than substantive. It noted that the parties’ reciprocal obligations were independent of whether the Maltese law complied with EU law. The adviser had judged the opinion to be reasonably defensible under the framework and information available when he issued it.

The consequences for operators are immediate. Bill 55 bars legal proceedings against MGA-licensed operators and prevents Maltese courts from enforcing foreign judgments in local grey-market disputes. The law was introduced in 2023 and has since faced criticism from players and operators who argue that it goes too far against EU principles.

AGBrief has been following Malta’s regulatory moves as they develop.

What Malta Bill 55 Actually Blocks

The bill has two effects. It prevents legal action against Maltese-licensed operators, and it blocks the recognition and enforcement in Malta of foreign judgments arising from claims against those operators. The scope matters more than the wording. A player in a grey-market jurisdiction who wins a refund case against an MGA-licensed operator may still have the judgment refused in Malta.

The April 2026 ECJ ruling that member states may bring proceedings against operators for failing to comply with local gambling law sits alongside the bill. It adds pressure on MGA-licensed operators to obtain local licences where they operate, even where the licence is not strictly required by local law. The bill does not answer that question.

The Bigger EU Gambling Cases Awaiting

Zammit told iGB that other cases before the ECJ may eventually force a ruling on Bill 55’s compatibility. The current judgment is narrow: it resolved a dispute about a legal opinion, not a dispute about the law itself. Operators relying on the bill’s protections should treat the issue as open.

The Malta Gaming Authority remains the regulator for licensed online gaming in the jurisdiction.

Frequently Asked Questions

What did the ECJ rule on Malta Bill 55?

The ECJ dismissed an Austrian court’s referral as inadmissible. It found that EU law was not necessary to decide a negligence claim between a litigation funder and its adviser. The judgment did not address whether Malta Bill 55 complies with EU law.

What does Malta Bill 55 prohibit?

The law bars legal proceedings against MGA-licensed operators and prevents Maltese courts from recognising or enforcing foreign judgments against them. It targets cross-border enforcement by players and litigation funders seeking refunds of gambling losses.

Why was the referral inadmissible?

The Austrian court’s request concerned a negligence dispute between two private parties. The ECJ held that the adviser could assess whether his opinion was defensible without first determining whether the Maltese law complies with EU law, so no interpretation was needed.

Does the ECJ ruling weaken Bill 55?

Not directly. The law still applies, but its compatibility with EU law remains untested. Other cases before the ECJ may eventually settle the question, and operators relying on the bill’s protections should treat the issue as unresolved.

What happened in April 2026?

The ECJ ruled that EU member states may bring legal proceedings against operators for failing to comply with local gambling laws. That decision sits alongside Bill 55 and adds pressure on MGA-licensed operators to obtain local licences in grey-market jurisdictions.

Who brought the case?

Spielerschutz Sigma, an Austrian litigation funder, sought compensation from a legal adviser after Malta refused to apply an Austrian judgment against a MGA-licensed operator. The adviser’s opinion had stated that Malta Bill 55 was incompatible with EU law.

This article has been thoroughly researched and reviewed by the CasinoBait editorial team to ensure accuracy and relevance for Asian casino players.

Kyle Kevin
Kyle Kevin
Kyle is an iGaming writer with over two years of experience covering online casinos, sports betting, slot providers, and gaming regulation across Asia. Based in the Philippines, Kyle specializes in breaking down complex casino industry news into clear, actionable content for Casino players. His work on CasinoBait.com focuses on the Southeast Asian gaming market.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Why Trust
Asia
Primary
Market
5+
Years
iGaming
100%
Editorial
Independent
License verified against PAGCOR, MGA & Curacao records
Payout reliability checked before every listing
Reviewed for Asian payment methods & local markets
No paid rankings — affiliate deals never influence ratings
Updated June 2026 — reviewed monthly
spot_img

Share post:

Subscribe

spot_img

Popular

More like this
Related

D.C. advances online casino bill, Florida targets DraftKings

D.C. advanced an online casino bill with a $2M licence fee and 25% AGGR tax. Florida's attorney general has threatened DraftKings over the 21 Rivals card game.

Prediction markets top of Senate CFTC nominee hearing

Prediction markets regulation could shift as CFTC nominees testify before the Senate Agriculture Committee on staffing cuts, court rulings and Kalshi litigation.

CFTC sports event contracts rule draws tribal opposition

The CFTC's proposal to treat sports event contracts as swaps drew 140 comments and tribal opposition. Tribes, the AGA and 43 states argue the agency lacks authority.

France online gambling draws younger, female players

France's regulated online gambling market grew 7.6% in 2025. Young adults aged 18-24 are the fastest-growing group, while poker accounts doubled since 2019.