The CFTC’s proposal to classify sports event contracts as swaps drew 140 public comments and immediate opposition from tribal gaming groups, the American Gaming Association and 43 states. The agency is now weighing whether to finalize the rule.
CFTC sports event contracts proposal drew 140 comments by its November 18 deadline, with most arriving on the final two days. Tribes, the American Gaming Association, a 43-state coalition and Utah oppose it; Kalshi, Coinbase and Polymarket US support it. The CFTC will now decide whether to finalize or revise the rule.
- Tribal Groups Oppose the CFTC Rule
- Who Supported the Proposal
- What Is At Stake Economically
- What Happens Next for Sports Contracts
Tribal gaming groups filed the loudest opposition to the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s proposal to classify sports event contracts as swaps. The National Congress of American Indians represents around 300 tribal nations and called for the withdrawal of the rule. It wrote that relabelling the wagers does not change their nature as gambling, and argued Congress never intended the CFTC to become a gambling regulator.
The California Nations Indian Gaming Association, the Oklahoma Indian Gaming Association, the Arizona Indian Gaming Association, the Tribal Alliance of Sovereign Indian Nations and several individual tribal governments filed submissions. The Ninth Circuit’s ruling in favour of two California tribes against Kalshi is also cited by opponents, because it found that sports event contracts sold on tribal lands could violate the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act even if they qualify as swaps.
AGBrief is tracking the fallout across tribal gaming jurisdictions.
Tribal Groups Oppose the CFTC Sports Event Contracts Rule
Oklahoma’s Alabama-Quassarte Tribal Town pushed hardest. The tribe filed the strongest support for the proposal, arguing that federally regulated event contracts and tribal gaming can coexist without undermining the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act. It also cited a reported $60,000 Kalshi position used by a Los Angeles hospitality group to hedge against the Dodgers missing the World Series, pointing at a commercial use the agency can defend.
The economic argument is blunt. The Federated Indians of Graton Rancheria warned that prediction-market sports contracts threaten the economic foundation of tribal governments. In contrast, three of the four tribes that partnered with Kalshi in October broke ranks with the rest of the opposition and supported federal oversight. Only the Kletsel Dehe Wintun Nation did not file. Utah’s governor and attorney general filed separately, raising addiction and household financial harm.
Who Backed the CFTC Sports Event Contracts Proposal
The financial industry lined up behind the agency. Kalshi, Polymarket US, Coinbase, Rothera, Gemini, Novig and Underdog endorsed the swap classification, alongside Andreessen Horowitz and the Coalition for Prediction Markets. Coinbase argued the proposal simply confirms what the Commodity Exchange Act already provides. Underdog said its exchange has self-certified more than 500 sports event contracts as swaps, with its clearinghouse and futures commission merchant operating under CFTC oversight.
The American Gaming Association argued the framework creates unequal treatment for products it considers functionally identical, and questioned whether the CFTC understands the size of the market it is regulating. Better Markets and Boyd Gaming opposed the rule as well, with the latter warning that a broad swap definition could eventually swallow traditional casino games. Gemini recommended changes to make the rule more defensible in court.
What Is at Stake Economically
The CFTC pegs monthly trading activity in sports event contracts at $1.5 billion. That figure reached more than $39 billion in the first week of November alone, so the volume under discussion is not marginal. Prediction-market operators argue that exchange-traded contracts differ from sportsbook wagers because participants set prices, positions can be traded before settlement, and contracts are cleared under federal exchange rules.
The debate over comment volume is also part of the story. The April advance notice drew over 3,500 comments, and a July proposal drew over 1,400. Both attracted a wide field that included former Sen. Christopher Dodd, NFL and NBA representatives, state regulators, responsible gambling groups and academics. This round drew far fewer, and most submissions came from tribal gaming interests and prediction-market operators. The narrower scope, focused on swaps rather than comprehensive trading rules, also explains part of the gap.
What Happens Next for Sports Contracts
The CFTC must now decide whether to finalize or revise the proposal. The agency has been aggressive in defending its authority over sports event contracts, and that posture suggests finalisation is the likely outcome. A finalized rule would give prediction-market operators clearer federal status for sports contracts and put further pressure on state regulators.
iGaming Business is monitoring the CFTC’s next filing for a decision date.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why did the CFTC propose classifying sports event contracts as swaps?
The agency proposes to include sports event contracts in the swap definition so that exchange-traded contracts receive federal exchange, clearing and reporting requirements. Operators argue this confirms existing law rather than creating a new category, because the contracts are already swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act.
Who opposed the CFTC sports event contracts rule?
The National Congress of American Indians, the California Nations Indian Gaming Association, the Oklahoma Indian Gaming Association, the Arizona Indian Gaming Association, the Tribal Alliance of Sovereign Indian Nations, 43 states plus Washington, Utah’s governor and attorney general, Better Markets and Boyd Gaming all opposed or cautioned against the rule.
How many comments did the CFTC receive?
The CFTC received 140 comments by the November 18 deadline, most of which arrived on the final two days. That is well below its April notice, which drew over 3,500 comments, and below the July proposal, which drew over 1,400.
Why did three Kalshi partner tribes back the rule?
Three of the four Kalshi partner tribes supported the swap classification, arguing that federally regulated event contracts and tribal gaming can coexist without undermining the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act. Only the Kletsel Dehe Wintun Nation did not file. The Alabama-Quassarte Tribal Town was the most vocal supporter.
How big is the sports event contract market?
The CFTC cites $1.5 billion in monthly trading activity. The figure reached over $39 billion during the first week of November alone. Underdog reported that its exchange has self-certified more than 500 sports event contracts as swaps with its CFTC-regulated clearinghouse.
What happens after the comment period?
The CFTC will now assess the submissions and decide whether to finalize or revise the proposal. Given the agency’s history of defending its authority over sports event contracts, finalisation appears likely, though tribal and state opposition could still influence the final scope.
This article has been thoroughly researched and reviewed by the CasinoBait editorial team to ensure accuracy and relevance for Asian casino players.


