An FBI special agent testified this week that six DraftKings microbets on Emmanuel Clase’s first pitch to Starling Marte totaled roughly $9,500 individually and paid out about $27,000 in winnings. Jurors watched a video in which co-conspirators danced to a Backstreet Boys hit before the allegedly fixed throw.
Pitch-rigging trial testimony centered on a May 19, 2023 extra-innings at-bat at Citi Field. Clase allegedly fixed a 98.5 mph cutter so it would be called a ball; the entourage bet it would exceed 94.5 mph. Six DraftKings microbets returned about $27,000 in winnings, and a total of 24 bets produced $26,543.51 net across $11,671 staked. The two Cleveland Guardians pitchers face at least 20 years each if convicted.
- The $27,000 Bet on One Pitch
- The Backstreet Boys Video
- Cockfighting Code and the Defense Case
- Will the Pitch-Rigging Trial Run Past Christmas
$27,000 is the headline number in the pitch-rigging trial so far. Six DraftKings microbets on the outcome of Emmanuel Clase’s first pitch to Starling Marte returned that figure, according to FBI special agent Ava Barnett. Individual bets ranged from several hundred dollars to $9,500, and every one of the six won for the bettors.
The pitch was thrown on 19 May 2023 at Citi Field, roughly 12 miles from the Brooklyn federal courthouse. Clase is a Cleveland Guardians reliever, and the group wagered whether his first pitch would clear 94.5 mph despite topping 100 mph on the radar gun.
The $27,000 Bet on One Pitch
Assistant US Attorney Rebecca Urquiola put the evidence in front of the jury with an Excel spreadsheet projected across several courtroom screens. That spreadsheet tracked 24 microbets in total, including wagers by Enoc Pena and Luis Alberto de Aza Baez.
The wider spreadsheet showed $11,671 staked and $26,543.51 in net wins, with the majority of bets landing. That figure covers more than just the Marte at-bat and reflects the group’s wider activity across the scheme.
AGBrief tracks betting markets and microbets across jurisdictions.
The Backstreet Boys video enters the pitch-rigging trial
The trial began on 4 November and has now run through two weeks of jury sessions in Brooklyn federal court. During Thursday’s session, Barnett played footage of Clase playing dominoes with friends, drinking Presidente, at a table bearing a Boston Red Sox logo.
Classmates Luis Arismendy Paca Mendez and Enoc Pena were present. Clase had given the group tickets to Citi Field for a four-game series against the Mets in May 2023. After the Guardians lost two of three to the Chicago White Sox, the mood was upbeat rather than gloomy. Between innings, Paca danced to “I Want It That Way” from the 1999 Backstreet Boys hit.
Cockfighting code and the defense’s rebuttal
Prosecutors say the entourage used coded language to conceal the nature of its fixed wagers. Pena has been cooperating with the government and appears to hold immunity, but defense attorneys have attacked his credibility, citing alleged lies on loan applications and tax filings.
Barnett described an exchange in which Clase referenced a “rooster” in the pit and then instructed someone to “play the third” after killing the first two. Prosecutors interpreted the language as code for a batter’s lineup spot or the pitch Clase allegedly intended to fix. Defense attorneys pushed back heavily on how far the agent’s interpretation went.
Will the pitch-rigging trial run past Christmas
Disputes over discovery and a supplemental motion seeking to admit a proffer statement from Vasquez have made the courtroom volatile. Defense counsel have characterized Pena as “uncredible” while presenting him as someone who lied on official forms.
The trial resumes Monday, with Jenner Olivo, a government witness and a former housemate of Pena and Vasquez in Nantucket, taking the stand. Urquiola is expected to examine Olivo on direct, including testimony about money sent by Pena to Paca in exchange for inside information.
iGaming Business has covered federal sports gambling prosecutions.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the pitch-rigging trial about?
Two Cleveland Guardians pitchers, Emmanuel Clase and Robinson Vasquez, are accused of conspiring to influence sporting contests by bribery and laundering money. The scheme involved 18 allegedly rigged pitches, beginning with Clase’s first throw to Starling Marte in extra innings on 19 May 2023. The trial started on 4 November and runs through early December.
How much was wagered on the Clase pitch?
Six DraftKings microbets on the outcome of Clase’s first pitch totaled roughly $9,500 in the largest bet and all six won. Across the full scheme, 24 bets staked $11,671 for net wins of $26,543.51, according to a government exhibit introduced in court.
What exactly did the FBI agent testify about?
Ava Barnett of the FBI’s Newark office testified about microbets and extracted chats, photos and videos. She described a Backstreet Boys video showing co-conspirators dancing at Citi Field before the Marte pitch, and later discussed Clase’s coded references to a “rooster” and “chicken number three” during the game.
Who is Luis Arismendy Paca Mendez?
Paca was Clase’s former Ohio roommate and a friend who danced with him before the Marte at-bat. He faces multiple charges, including making false statements to the FBI. Although he is not a co-defendant, he is currently being held without bail.
What are the potential sentences?
The two Guardians pitchers face at least 20 years in federal prison each if convicted. Vasquez is separately charged with conspiracy to commit wire fraud. All three defendants, including Pena, have pleaded not guilty.
What is next for the pitch-rigging trial?
The jury will resume Monday with Jenner Olivo, a former housemate of Pena and Vasquez in Nantucket, on the stand for the government. The case has been moving quickly, with disputes over discovery and a supplemental motion creating pressure to finish before the holiday break.
This article has been thoroughly researched and reviewed by the CasinoBait editorial team to ensure accuracy and relevance for Asian casino players.


