Prediction markets top of Senate CFTC nominee hearing

Date:

Kyle Kevin
Kyle Kevin
iGaming Writer
Fact Checked

Prediction markets regulation could shift within the year as two Commodity Futures Trading Commission nominees testified before the Senate Agriculture Committee and promised to rebuild a staffed-down regulator.

Quick Answer

Prediction markets regulation could change soon. Senate Agriculture Committee nominees Nathan Anonick and Matthew Rowland testified on Tuesday and neither embraced nor rejected the CFTC’s rulemaking approach. Both pledged to strengthen the commission’s ranks. CFTC staff numbers were 21% below the previous 10-year average at the end of 2025.

In This Article
  • Prediction Markets Regulation Comes to the Committee
  • Nominees Split Over the Court’s Path
  • Enforcement Has Already Slipped
  • What the Senate Must Now Do

Prediction markets regulation could be rewritten inside the next term. Senate Agriculture Committee Chair John Boozman asked two nominees to appear before his panel on Tuesday. They are Nathan Anonick, a Republican serving as derivatives counsel to Boozman, and Matthew Rowland, a Democrat serving as the committee’s CFTC detailee. Both nominations came from President Donald Trump last week, and both would fill open seats on a commission that has operated with a single chairman, Michael Selig, for almost a year.

The commission is normally staffed by five commissioners, no more than three of them from the same party. As a result, confirming these two leaves at least one Democratic seat still open, and Democrats won both chambers in the midterm elections. Anonick’s term runs through June 2031 and Rowland’s through April 2028.

Prediction Markets Regulation Comes to the Committee

Neither nominee took a position on the agency’s rulemaking approach. Both promised to listen to stakeholders and expand the commission. Committee members from both parties applauded the pledges, and Boozman asked for confirmation to move as quickly as possible.

Rowland told the panel that a Supreme Court decision on prediction markets is likely to land within the next term or the one after, and that the commission would be bound by it. Anonick, facing pressure from Democratic members, said he would follow any court ruling and conduct a robust, thorough fact-finding process. His commitment is significant, because the courts are far from settled.

Nominees Split Over the Court’s Path

Four federal Circuit Courts have already ruled on prediction-market cases. The Ninth, Sixth and Fourth Circuits sided with state jurisdiction, while the Third Circuit found federal preemption. That split makes the outcome of the agency’s rulemaking genuinely uncertain. Rowland asked the panel to balance public interest against the economic usefulness of these contracts, a reference to the commission’s public interest test for contract markets.

Both nominees declined to make broad statements about sports event contracts, and the reason is structural. The CFTC’s prediction markets rulemaking is still open, and litigation is piling up against both the agency and the operators at the centre of it, Kalshi and Polymarket. Anonick described the fractured circuit decisions as complex and confusing.

Enforcement Has Already Slipped

The most bipartisan issue was staffing. The commission is short commissioners and short personnel. According to the US Office of Personnel Management, staff numbers at the end of 2025 were 21% below the previous 10-year average. The agency’s annual report also showed a sharp drop in enforcement actions last year against its own historical baseline.

Anonick said he would examine the staffing data, the hiring plan and the technical expertise the agency believes it is missing. Rowland said he looks forward to learning more about Chair Selig’s plan to hire staff and called appropriately staffing and resourcing the agency a high priority.

KEY FACTS
Committee Panel
Senate Agriculture
Nominees
Anonick + Rowland
Staff Shortfall
21% below avg
Rowland’s Term
To Apr 2028
Anonick’s Term
To Jun 2031
Current Commission
1 of 5 seats
Opinion Split
3 vs 1 circuits
Chairman
Michael Selig

What the Senate Must Now Do

The hearing closed without a vote, leaving the record for two days. Both the committee and the full Senate must approve the nominations before either takes effect. Boozman wants both confirmed as soon as possible, and the pressure on the panel is now procedural rather than philosophical.

AGBrief is tracking confirmation and the prediction market rulemaking.

iGaming Business has documented the commission’s expanding role across gaming markets.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who testified before the Senate committee?

Nathan Anonick, a Republican derivatives counsel to Senator John Boozman, and Matthew Rowland, a Democrat and the committee’s CFTC detailee, testified Tuesday. Both nominated by President Trump last week to serve as CFTC commissioners.

Why does prediction markets regulation matter?

The CFTC is proposing to regulate prediction market contracts as swaps, and prediction markets operators want that clarity. Three of four federal circuits have sided with state jurisdiction over sports contracts, leaving the issue unresolved until the Supreme Court decides.

How many commissioners will there eventually be?

The CFTC normally has five commissioners, with no more than three from one party. Confirming Anonick and Rowland leaves at least one Democratic seat open, so the commission will not be full until the Senate approves the remaining nominations.

Why did Anonick commit to fact-finding?

Democratic members pressed Anonick about prediction markets after the split circuit rulings. He pledged to follow any court decision and run a robust, thorough fact-finding process, so the agency’s approach could change once the courts clarify the law.

Why is CFTC enforcement declining?

Staff counts at the end of 2025 were 21% below the previous 10-year average, and the agency recorded fewer enforcement actions last year than its own history. Anonick said he would study the staffing plan and identify where technical expertise is missing.

What happens after the hearing?

The record is closed for two days before the committee votes. Both the committee and the full Senate must approve each nomination, and Boozman wants both confirmed quickly. The prediction market rulemaking continues regardless of the outcome.

This article has been thoroughly researched and reviewed by the CasinoBait editorial team to ensure accuracy and relevance for Asian casino players.

Kyle Kevin
Kyle Kevin
Kyle is an iGaming writer with over two years of experience covering online casinos, sports betting, slot providers, and gaming regulation across Asia. Based in the Philippines, Kyle specializes in breaking down complex casino industry news into clear, actionable content for Casino players. His work on CasinoBait.com focuses on the Southeast Asian gaming market.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Why Trust
Asia
Primary
Market
5+
Years
iGaming
100%
Editorial
Independent
License verified against PAGCOR, MGA & Curacao records
Payout reliability checked before every listing
Reviewed for Asian payment methods & local markets
No paid rankings — affiliate deals never influence ratings
Updated June 2026 — reviewed monthly
spot_img

Share post:

Subscribe

spot_img

Popular

More like this
Related

CFTC sports event contracts rule draws tribal opposition

The CFTC's proposal to treat sports event contracts as swaps drew 140 comments and tribal opposition. Tribes, the AGA and 43 states argue the agency lacks authority.

France online gambling draws younger, female players

France's regulated online gambling market grew 7.6% in 2025. Young adults aged 18-24 are the fastest-growing group, while poker accounts doubled since 2019.

Colombia ousts Coljuegos chief over degree row

Colombian President Abelardo de la Espriella demanded Coljuegos chief Jaime Vives Pinedo step down after a postgraduate degree was reportedly earned in two months.

Bradley Walsh’s fake Million Pound Shot show faces backlash

Channel 4's new game show has players betting real money, only to reveal it was fake. The Betting and Gaming Council says the programme ignored its rebuttal.